If you're trying to judge a talent based on what raid slots it lets you replace, then yes, ILotP doesn't measure up. Personally, I think that's a really bad standard. ALL that I am interested in is to what degree will it supplement what I'm getting in my raids. For me and for other rogues, that is the best new talent druids received. We're grouped with a feral druid more often than we are with a shadow-priest. Shadow-priests don't buff our damage, ferals do. And now ferals can give us healing. Not all that much, no, but we're often left with nothing but pots, bandages and enchants anyway.