With all the Hype on World of Warcraft I was intrested in seeing what Blizzard created this time. My being a Diablo and Diablo ][ graduate, I thought I'll give World of Warcraft a try.
I'm NO authority ... on exactly how to program a good game but World of Warcraft has not been programmed with any kind of Reality or Believability in mind. Maybe it’s more of the Designers fault and not the programmers however, the product needs to be changed.
BEFORE you say yayaya .... blablabla... Try this for yourself.
Take your Highest level character to a newbie zone, remove your weapon, then bare hand slap a 1st level creature there, then turn your attacking off before you kill it. Took me three times to get this done. In using a caster use your first level Direct Damage spell. Once just once to get it attacking you. Once you have one attacking you and your not killing it watch how many hp’s that creature takes from you with each hit. Let it hit you say 10 - 20 times then Kill it. Scroll back through the battle log. Add the hp's up for say 10 shots (I did 20). Take your armor off... yes OFF, put it in the Backpack or a bag. Now that you have nothing on but your underware slap another of the same creature. Once again add the amount of Hp’s it has removed in the same number of hits.
Did the amount of Hp’s removed change? I’m not talking 1 or 2 hp’s here I’m talking as it SHOULD have changed dramatically. Full plate to naked....and I had 2 (two) hp’s difference with 20 hits. OK the first level only does one (1) point of damage with each hit but with an AC of around 1k Warrior and 550 Druid it didn't make any difference for either of them.
Now that you tried it with first level critter try one you will get exp from. Did the amout of HP's removed change? Mine didn't in 20 hits with the Warrior had a 10 point difference .. the druid had 8. The wearing of Armor doens't make any difference. I did this with several different levels of creatures and I'm Telling you NOW ARMOR USE DOESN'T MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE! ... AND it REALLY SHOULD!!!
IF ... any of you come up with a significant reason to wear armor post it here please. I've only been playin WoW since Christmas 2004 ... it was a gift to myself. My warrior is just 26 .. the Druid is just 19. Maybe armor does something in upper levels. If not the lets all HUNT NAKED!
Another ISSUE I have with WoW is that creatures do not DROP believable drops. In killing my first or second wolf as a 1st level Human Warrior I was REALLY surprised to get a Chain Mail Chest piece. Later on I was fighting some humanoid creature (Kobold maybe) who was holding a Mace looking weapon with a shield and when it fell to the ground I ended up as my loot a Two Handed sword.....mmmm
After playing EverQuest for 5 years I got sick of it. (28 Bard, 51 Druid, 36 Cleric, 34 Enchanter, 28 Paladin, 32 Warrior, 45 Wizard... those are from just 1 server and I was on 6 different servers) I showed EQ to my Mac friends. They rushed out to buy it when it showed up for Mac . . . only we found out that we can’t play together. I thought since Blizzard supports Mac and PC playing together I’d give this a go. I’ve showed this to the fore mentioned Mac friends and none of them are rushing to buy. I had (we had) hoped for better. For those of you who have not played EQ, the treasure drops are believable. In that, if the creature your fighting is hitting you with a mace YOU will get that MACE... not a Two Handed Sword. Wolves do not drop armor, shields or weapons, etc. they drop wolf hides and wolf meat.
It’s nice that Blizzard Entertainment has produced this game but, it needs work. The designers need to set down with the programmers and GAMER’s to get these major flaws corrected. I and I say I but I know several others, want my RP game to have believability as well as to be pretty. The game has nice graphics. The programming just needs a few tweaks to the treasures dropped and add a hit damage verses Armor Class subroutine.